Mateys Restaurant

Mateys Restaurant is a taste of the Caribbean and a song away from the pristine beaches of the Indiana dunes. When you visit us, you’ll never leave hungry. The Chart Room, our casual dining room, is in a nautical atmosphere with a cozy Cocktail Lounge for the adult crowd, strung with buoys and fishing nets throughout the bar, captain’s chairs at the tables, tropical music on the sound system and a laid-back feel. The menu is filled with a variety of surf and turf options such as beer battered lake perch, crab cakes, BBQ pulled pork, and our bleu cheese burger. And if you’re in the mood for both, try our Steak and Cake for a juicy 8 ounce ribeye and a homemade crab cake.

And don’t miss our Sports Bar. It is a hub of activity with video games, Bags, Golden Tee golf, pool table, dart machine, as well as beer pong for the more ‘salty dogs’ and nonstop sports coverage on its 6 big screen TV’s.

When it’s boating season, our three-level Tiki Deck is filled with a fantastic crowd. People are drinking cocktails, dining in the sunshine or under the stars, and enjoying the great lake view. Climb the stairs to the Tiki Deck and you will begin to wonder … are you still in Michigan City, or by some chance are you in a tropical bar in the Florida Keys?

We look forward to seeing you soon at our restaurant, or bars. At Matey’s, there is somewhere and something for everyone. Come bask in the sun with us.